Choo Only Indian Deserving of All-Star Nod (For Now)

Online balloting for the All-Star Game went live recently and fans can now vote for the ASG starters, as they could in years past. And most likely, as in years past, fans will screw at least one deserving player out of a roster spot because they voted in some big name having a crappy season. I really hate fan voting. I’m not prepared to reveal my proposal on how to improve the All-Star Game (July 13th is a ways off), I will say I really hate fans voting the starters. I’m cool with fans voting in the final player, but that’s about it.

Anyways, while I highly doubt there will be any ballot stuffing by Tribe fans ala 1998. Nor should there be. Mike Redmond will not be going to Anaheim, since the All-Star game is mostly about offensive numbers, no one gives a damn how well he’s handled the Tribe staff. No one cares about the Redmond Effect. He will also not be there because he’s Mike Redmond and has a .211 OBP.

No, the only Indians player Tribe fans should vote for in good conscience is OF Shin-Soo Choo.

The AL Player of the Week last week, Choo has been the only consistent Indian on offense. Although his defense has been shaky, Choo has been chugging along, with 4 home runs, .464 OBP, 1.123 OPS and 3 stolen bases.

I wrote earlier in the season that I thought the Indians would only have 1 All-Star, and that it would be Grady Sizemore. Well while two weeks doesn’t guarantee an All-Star appearance, I still think the Indians will have only one representative, but right now it’s looking like that rep will be Shin-Soo Choo.

Finally, Mat Germain of Fansided’s terrific Call to the Pen has a very informative write-up of Indians pitching prospect TJ House. I’ll admit to not being too familiar with House, but after reading this glowing review of his skills, I must admit I’m a little excited. Be sure to check it out.

Next Indians Game View full schedule »
Thursday, Aug 2828 Aug7:10at Chicago White SoxBuy Tickets

Tags: Grady Sizemore Shin Soo Choo Tj House

  • Pingback: Baseball Side of FanSided (4/24) | Call to the Pen

  • http://facebook Jason

    It’s funny how initial reaction’s or over reaction’d by media get a lot of attention because you get away with it and get paid for it. In this case, its rediculous that the only player deserving of an All-Star selection would be Choo. Two strong candidates that are also deserving of a selection are Talbot, and Carmona. Especially if your “already” making a selection after only the first month of baseball.

  • Ed Carroll

    1. I don’t get paid for this.

    2. Fans don’t vote for the pitchers, except in the case of the final roster spot.

    3. Yes, it’s an incredibly small sample size (as is for any All-Star selection, really). But at the time of writing this, Talbot and Carmona had each only made three starts, and that’s not enough for me to base my judgment on. If they continue to pitch well, they will earn All-Star consideration. But right now, the Tribe is only deserving of one All-Star, and that is Shin-Soo Choo.

  • Wesley (CardiacCane)

    Good stuff Ed. One day we will be rewarded with another good team and hopefully finally get that world series, but until then its just another sub par season. I’m Wesley by the way, I do the CardiacCane blog for the Carolina Hurricanes, but grew up around the Kinston Indians and did baseball camp with Carmona, Martinez, and Sizemore. Go luck with your blog