Rick Osentoski-US PRESSWIRE

Indians, Yankees Talking Travis Hafner for A.J. Burnett Trade

This weekend, we heard speculation that the Cleveland Indians might be involved in the trade talks with the Yankees regarding right-handed starting pitcher A.J. Burnett. Joel Sherman had floated the idea that the Indians could trade DH Travis Hafner to clear payroll for Burnett, and Stephanie Liscio had suggested that Cleveland could trade Hafner for Burnett straight-up.

On Monday, I dismissed the idea of trading Hafner for Burnett (whether directly or indirectly) as foolish for the Indians; given the Tribe’s great pitching depth and the lack of same at DH, it didn’t make sense for to Cleveland to make such a swap it probably wouldn’t bring the team any salary relief. And that was before the Indians signed Jon Garland.


To be fair, Heyman makes it clear that the Indians aren’t sure about whether the deal is worth it. But that they’re seriouslt considering it is disconcerting.

Who do the Indians expect to use at DH if Hafner’s gone? Shelley Duncan? Russ Canzler? Perhaps they would requisition one of Jason Kipnis or Carlos Santana‘s gloves, thus robbing either player of his great positional value.

Would A.J. Burnett even have a spot on this team? Justin Masterson, Ubaldo Jimenez, Derek Lowe, and Josh Tomlin seem to be all but guaranteed slots in the rotation. Would Burnett really be that much better than Jon Garland or Kevin Slowey or Jeanmar Gomez or David Huff or Zach McAllister or Scott Barnes (all of whom are already in the mix for the final rotation spot)? Setting aside the margin, would he even be the best choice from that group?

Burnett wouldn’t make this team that much better, and losing Hafner would make it a whole lot worse. To make this deal would be trading from a weakness to add unnecessary strength; let’s hope the front office realizes that before it’s too late.

UPDATE: Some good news:

Crisis averted.

Don’t forget to subscribe to our RSS feedLike us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter!

Next Indians Game View full schedule »
Monday, Sep 11 Sep4:05Detroit TigersBuy Tickets

Tags: A.j. Burnett New York Yankees Travis Hafner

  • MrNegative1

    My guess: Since Jon Heyman is a mouthpiece for Scott Boras he is delivering a message to Huntington to take the deal.

    If I’m the Pirates I will take AJ and pay only 10 mil for him.

    NY seems to think they can Pitt to pay 13 to 15 million.

    I be most impressed with Huntington if he did a 11th hour about face and acquired Wandy Rodriguez, Jeff Niemann, Brett Meyers, or Wade Davis.

    So, let’s assume I’m completely wrong. Would the Indians be better off with AJ Burnett at 12 mil over the next 2 years and Johnny Damon or Vlad Guerrero at DH in 2012 for around 2.5 mil and save a few mil in salary?