Jennifer Stewart-US PRESSWIRE

Could Indians Trade for Justin Upton and Trevor Bauer?

Something happened when the Indians traded for Mike Aviles last week: Asdrubal Cabrera became expendable. I like Asdrubal, but it’s time to think bold, and the way he has tanked in August the past two years has to scare you.

So call the Diamondbacks, offer them Cabrera and Chris Perez for Justin Upton and Trevor Bauer. Yes, really.

Upton is on track to make $8.5 million next year, so you can add him to the payroll and still sign a pitcher with the rest of the money freed up from Hafner’s departure. Upton has had some off-field issues and the Diamondbacks soured on Bauer last year, but the Indians have to gamble, and the fact that Upton was fourth in the MVP vote just a year ago shows that the upside is definitely there. Besides, Terry Francona managed Manny Ramirez so Upton won’t scare him, and Bauer will be 22 next year, so he has a good chance to figure it out in the next year or two. Meanwhile, Cabrera and Perez would fill Arizona’s two biggest holes, so they will listen—especially when they think hard about having Heath Bell as their closer.

Think of the lineup this would give Cleveland: Michael Brantley, Kevin Youkilis (I’m assuming the Indians could sign him for around two years and $14 million), Shin-Soo Choo, Justin Upton, Carlos Santana, Russ Canzler, Lonnie Chisenhall, Mike Aviles, and Jason Kipnis. Left-right left all the way through. Did you ever think we’d see that in Cleveland again? Five or six guys in that lineup have the potential to hit 20 homers, and an outfield of Brantley, Upton, and Choo would be one of the best in MLB.

Who knows if Bauer will be ready next year, but his upside would be a number three starter at worst. Add him and a free agent to a rotation of Justin Masterson, Zach McAllister, and Ubaldo Jimenez, and it suddenly things are looking up at Progressive Field. And if anyone falters, Carlos Carrasco should be ready to reclaim his rotation spot.

Trading Perez would be a gamble, especially now that Esmil Rogers is gone. It would likely mean that Nick Hagadone or Cody Allen will be pitching in the late innings next year. I can live with that, because it’s a gamble based on real potential, unlike, say, hoping Shelley Duncan can play left field. Plus, it would be worth losing him if it means bringing Upton and Bauer to Northeast Ohio.

If the Indians can swing a deal like this, it makes more sense to go for it in 2013 than to blow it up. With a little luck and a couple complementary parts, this is a contending team. If things go wrong you the rebuilding can start in June, but in the meantime let’s people a reason to buy some tickets in April and May.

Would this deal work?

  • No, the Diamondbacks wouldn't do it (51%, 90 Votes)
  • Yes (34%, 60 Votes)
  • No, the Indians wouldn't do it (12%, 21 Votes)
  • No, neither team would do it (3%, 7 Votes)

Total Voters: 178

Loading ... Loading ...

Next Indians Game View full schedule »
Monday, Sep 11 Sep4:05Detroit TigersBuy Tickets

Tags: Arizona Diamondbacks Asdrubal Cabrera Chris Perez Cleveland Indians Justin Upton Kevin Youkilis Trevor Bauer

  • Manuel Möller

    there’s one mistake- the dbacks have j.j. putz as their closer – meaning they don’t need perez. i would do a cabrera – upton deal in a heartbeat, no question!

    • Hermie13

      Was about to post the exact same thing.

      Heath Bell is not their closer; he’s their setup man. Putz was better than Chris Perez was this year…and likely to be cheaper as they picked up his $6.5M option (Perez likely will make about $7M).

      Even if this wasn’t the case, you’re basically suggesting that Cabrera for Upton is a fair trade (it’s not, D’backs would need more) and that Chris Perez is worth Bauer straight up….nothing could be further from the truth there.

      The D’backs would never do this deal. Now maybe if we took Heath Bell from them but even then, doubtful.

  • Hermie13

    Also, I thought Upton was making $9.75M next year, not just $8.5M. Not a huge difference though.

  • Bob W

    This is quite possibly the most absurd trade rumor I’ve ever heard.
    Problem #1: D-Backs already have a closer in JJ Putz (might I also mention that they also have one of the best set-up guys in the game in David Hernandez)
    Problem #2: The D-Backs have announced Trevor Bauer will not be traded
    Problem #3: Heath Bell is the 7th inning guy
    Problem #4: A lot more than Cabrera is needed for Upton

  • James Joseph Kalmer III

    Well, the one major, glaring problem with this scenario is the fact that Upton has a limited no trade clause that includes the Indians

  • Pingback: Are the Cleveland Indians Too Good to Get Better? — Wahoo's on First