Aug 1, 2013; Cleveland, OH, USA; Cleveland Indians starting pitcher Justin Masterson (63) waits to be taken from the game during the seventh inning against the Chicago White Sox at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports

Indians Brass Weighs in On Masterson Talks


Chris Antonetti and Terry Francona Explain Masterson Dilemma

The Indians and Justin Masterson have agreed to put any and all contract extension talks on hold. That would be acceptable if neither side were trying to get a deal done. However, after reports surfaced on Thursday night that both sides had made offers that were subsequently rejected, it’s hard to think they couldn’t have gotten something done.

It become especially more painful when you realize that Justin Masterson attempted to give the Indians a home town discount.

Paul Hoynes and Ken Rosenthal both reported that Masterson had made an offer to the Indians for something around three years and $51-million dollars. That’s a slightly more team friendly deal than the one signed by the Reds’ Homer Bailey. You know, the same Homer Bailey and the same contract that were expected to be the bench marks for Masterson’s future earnings. Instead of taking the discount, the Indians turned down Masterson’ proposal and low balled him with 2 years $28-million.

Naturally, Masterson turned that offer down. That is how we came to find ourselves in this current situation with the ace of the staff now looking to hit free agency at the end of the year. In other words, Masterson is probably headed out-of-town either prior to the trade deadline, or via free agency. That is unless they can reach some sort of agreement on a contract between now and then, something that seems next to impossible.

On Friday, both Chris Antonetti and Terry Francona filled the media in on where things stand and how the situation came to be. A lot of good things were said, particularly about Masterson. Both Antonetti and Francona heaped a ton of praise on the big righty, explaining that they want nothing more than for him to be in Cleveland beyond just the 2014 season. Of course, this then raises the question as to why they aren’t working harder to pin down a deal, but that is a conversation for a different day.

In the meantime, we have an explanation from two of the Indians top men why Masterson has yet to be extended. Hopefully, the next time they talk about Masterson and a contract, it will be to announce a multi-year extension. Until then, you can watch video of both men explaining the situation in the video below (If video player fails to load, refresh page).

Tags: Cleveland Indians Justin Masterson

  • Letterman007

    The Indian’s front office, Sharponetti consortium, Is cheap and there is about a 2% chance they resign Masterson! Yet they can’t figure out why the attendance is so far down? Mostly because your idea is line my pockets first and then the change that falls to the floor is their operating expenses!! This year they had a shot at winning the fans back and made NO attempt to do so in their off season moves!! Basically they went dumpster diving, as normal, and have done literally nothing to up grade what they had !! Wrong direction for winning fans back in the seats!!

  • Gary

    Blah, blah, blah………………… Another potential Cy Young award winner will walk next season because of these cheap inept FO personnel of the Cleveland Indians. Instead, they spend money on other teams castoffs, has beens and injured old farts. After a very promising season last year, one would think any team in their right mind would try to improve on that. But, not Cleveland. Like all their sports teams.

  • Alan Nolt

    I do not blame the Indians for not signing Masterson to a long term contract. People forget they signed Jake Westbrook and Travis Hafner and we all know how that turned out. It is really dangerous to commit that much money to a pitcher. Just look at Atlanta and Oakland. If Masty leaves that is the reality of free agency. I root for the players that have Cleveland on their uniforms.